As small colleges shutter, towns left to examine future

In this Friday, Sept. 20, 2019 photograph, a Green Mountain College sign is on display among the goods to be sold at an auction at the school in Poultney, Vt. The school closed in May and now the town that hosted it for 185 years is awaiting to hear what will become of the campus. (AP Photo/Lisa Rathke)
In this Friday, Sept. 20, 2019 photograph, a Green Mountain College sign is on display among the goods to be sold at an auction at the school in Poultney, Vt. The school closed in May and now the town that hosted it for 185 years is awaiting to hear what will become of the campus. (AP Photo/Lisa Rathke)

POULTNEY, Vt. -- As colleges and universities come alive this fall, some campuses sit closed and empty after succumbing to a recent wave of fewer students and financial challenges.

Now communities that long hosted those historic institutions and relied on them for an economic boost -- and their very identity -- are left to adapt to the vacancy and wonder what comes next.

In Poultney, Vt., population 3,300, Green Mountain College had occupied a prominent spot at the end of the main street for 185 years. That changed in the spring, when the environmentally minded liberal arts school closed after commencement, citing a drop in enrollment and financial challenges.

The closure "literally changed the entire town of Poultney," said Mel Kingsley, who runs Mel's Place Hair Salon several blocks from campus and got 30% of her business from students.

"The town came alive every time the students came back, and you can feel the difference," she said.

Besides the day-to-day loss of students and school employees, communities also lose the graduates who stick around.

Sophia Vincenza Milkowski of New York City graduated two years ago and stayed in Poultney because she liked it so much.

"We're still trying to figure out what Poultney even is now without it there," she said during a break from work at a taco restaurant.

"We're all feeling its absence," she said, "whether we were a part of the college or not."

Across the country, 71 private nonprofit colleges and universities have closed since 1995, including schools that announced they would shutter in June 2020, according to the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities.

Just 12 independent institutions have opened in that period, while 29 have merged, the association said.

Schools have grappled with a shift toward more career-oriented training and a decline in the number of college-age students. Now towns are left dealing with the fallout.

Hiwassee College closed in the spring in rural, mostly white Madisonville, Tenn. Not only is the community losing one of its largest employers, but also "one small but important window into a larger, more diverse world," Roland King, former spokesman for the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities, wrote in a newspaper editorial.

In urban areas, some private colleges that have closed have been taken over by larger institutions, or developers.

The Newbury College campus in the Boston area recently sold for $34 million to investors in senior citizen care housing and medical office-related projects.

New fits for shuttered college campuses in smaller cities could be harder to find, leaving those communities in limbo.

In Vermont, besides Green Mountain College, the shuttered Southern Vermont College is also up for sale, and the College of St. Joseph in Rutland is trying to reinvent itself as a professional training and education center after it lost its accreditation last spring.

There's interest in the Green Mountain College campus but no deals have been signed, said Robert Allen, the last serving president of the school.

Down the street, the customer count is down at Bob Williams' hardware store, where students would buy fans and desk lamps and college maintenance workers would sometimes be in several times a day.

"We're anxiously looking forward to having something take over," Williams said.

A Section on 09/29/2019

Upcoming Events