Lawmakers who want tougher standards for evacuating aircraft in an emergency have criticized the Federal Aviation Administration for what they consider unrealistic simulations, and now they are calling for a do-over of current evacuation tests.
Decades-old federal rules require that planes be designed so that passengers can escape the cabin within 90 seconds in case of fire or some other emergency, even with half the exits blocked. Critics say the FAA has been lax in ensuring that today's airliners -- with more seats and narrower rows -- meet that standard.
They point to incidents including an American Airlines plane that caught fire on the ground in Chicago in 2016. Video from inside the plane showed panicked passengers clogging the aisle as they waited to slide down emergency chutes. Twenty people were injured in the chaotic escape.
"It should not -- it cannot -- take another tragedy to bring our aircraft evacuation standards up to date," Sen. Tammy Duckworth, D-Ill., said in announcing legislation she and others introduced recently to require changes in how FAA conducts evacuation tests.
When the FAA ran drills on an aircraft cabin mock-up in Oklahoma City in 2019, all the volunteers who took part were able-bodied adults under 60.
The FAA's administrator at the time acknowledged that the tests provided "useful, but not necessarily definitive information."
The FAA grudgingly conducted those tests only after Congress ordered the agency to come up with minimums for the size of airline seats and the distance between rows. Lawmakers said new standards are necessary because Americans are getting heavier while airlines are cramming more seats on planes.
The FAA declined to comment but has previously said the chance that passengers will survive an emergency is very high. The agency has resisted efforts to set minimum standards for seat size and distance between rows, saying those are issues of comfort, not safety. A federal appeals court ruled in FAA's favor this year.
Airlines have been making seats narrower and reducing legroom to squeeze more passengers on every flight. The distance from a seatback to the one in front or behind it -- airlines call that "pitch" -- used to measure about 35 inches; now it's 28 inches on some airlines and 31 or 32 inches on others.
Duckworth's legislation would require FAA standards to consider seat size, the layout of rows, the presence of carry-on bags, purses and briefcases -- even though passengers are told to leave those items behind -- and a real-world range of passengers including children, seniors and people with disabilities.
Major unions representing flight attendants support the bill, as do Paralyzed Veterans of America, Muscular Dystrophy Association and groups representing people who are blind, deaf or autistic.