Residents undercut wildfire prevention

Some property owners resist California’s efforts to clear brush in dense forests

A fire prevention crew removes vegetation along California’s Route 17 in November near Redwood Estates, Calif.
A fire prevention crew removes vegetation along California’s Route 17 in November near Redwood Estates, Calif.

SANTA CRUZ MOUNTAINS, Calif. -- Buzzing chain saws are interrupted by the frequent crash of breaking branches as crews fell towering trees and clear tangled brush in the densely forested Santa Cruz Mountains south of San Francisco.

Their goal: to protect communities such as Redwood Estates, where giant redwoods loom over the houses of tech workers who live in the wooded community just 20 miles from the heart of Silicon Valley. With California's increasingly warm, dry and overgrown landscape, wildfire has become a perpetual danger.

Among the most important tools the state has against fires is to mimic their effects: thinning trees and brush by hand to reduce the amount of vegetation that would become fuel in a fire, and using controlled burns to keep undergrowth and shrub lands in check.

State lawmakers committed more than $200 million annually to fire-prevention efforts and Gov. Gavin Newsom wants to spend even more, motivated by infernos such as one last year that killed 85 people in Paradise, Calif., some of whom died in their cars while trying to flee.

Yet officials say efforts to make areas such as the road corridor in Northern California more fire safe are undercut by property owners who refuse to let crews work on their property. Offered the choice between clearing vegetation-choked areas or retaining greenery that acts as a shield against the din of the nearby highway, a small minority opted for privacy over safety or said they'd do the work themselves.

That means patches of low-lying shrubs and some thickets of trees will remain when the job wraps up next year. As a result, future fires will retain potential avenues to spread into residential areas and threaten people and property.

"It's a chink in the armor," said Ed Orre, division chief with the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection. "If that property catches fire, then you get a chain-reaction, domino effect ... It compromises the effectiveness of the entire project."

Climate change and decades of lax land management practices put the U.S. West on a collision course with out-of-control wildfires, and authorities are now rushing to limit the potential damage from blazes that threaten year-round.

Since 1970, the amount of land burned each year in California has increased fivefold. Across the 11 Western states, acreage burned annually has doubled since 1984. Over the past three years, fires have killed 149 people and destroyed almost 25,000 homes across the state.

California is now nearly 3 degrees warmer than in 1990 due to climate change, with hotter temperatures during the Golden State's long dry season removing moisture from plants and soils, said Park Williams, a climate scientist at Columbia University.

"I see the recent wildfires as a tidal wave -- it's going to be very hard to stop that," Williams said.

Rapid residential development in recent decades boosted populations in high-risk areas. Almost 2 million homes are in flammable areas in Western states, said Jennifer Balch, a fire expert at the University of Colorado.

Some common but non-native plants -- including eucalyptus trees, cheatgrass and pernicious shrubs such as French and Scotch broom -- burn more readily than native species.

Although it's not feasible to manually thin all the forests and shrub land in California, targeted efforts to remove flammable vegetation in areas of high human activity can effectively reduce the chance of major fires.

"If we're going to do field treatment, we have to do it where it matters most -- where people live and work," Balch said.

While lightning strikes can start wildfires, today more than 95% in California are started by people -- mostly accidentally. Fires are sparked by downed power lines, campfires, mechanical equipment such as chain saws, and even hot vehicle exhaust pipes touching dry grass.

Managing the risk of wildfires isn't only the job of firefighters, say experts.

The most important prevention strategy is education -- teaching people about what starts accidental fires, and how to minimize them. They recommend avoiding highly flammable materials for roofs and decks, and not planting fire-prone non-native species.

Yet these steps won't entirely keep the flames away.

A Section on 12/14/2019

Upcoming Events