OTHERS SAY

A judge walks into a bar . . .

Have you heard the one about the judge who moonlighted as a comedian? It wasn’t a laughing matter for the New Jersey Supreme Court, which ruled recently that Municipal Court Judge Vince Sicari-who also appeared in comedy clubs and on television under the name Vince August-couldn’t judge by day and joke by night. So Sicari is hanging up his robe.

We understand the Supreme Court’s concern about the importance of judicial impartiality and the appearance thereof (as a lawyer might say). Still, it’s depressing that the court believes that some citizens of South Hackensack, N.J., wouldn’t be able to differentiate between a real-life judge and a show business persona.

No one would mistake Sicari for Antonin Scalia. The Municipal Court on which he served part time-receiving a salary of $13,000-deals with parking tickets, bad checks, fish and game violations, and minor criminal offenses. But even the humblest of magistrates is covered-appropriately-by canons of ethics that require judges “to avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety” and to maintain “high standards of conduct.”

The Supreme Court said Sicari’s dual career was incompatible with such standards.

So what was the problem? The court expressed concern that a litigant, witness or lawyer would mix up the man on the bench with the comic who made self-deprecating jokes about his Italian American upbringing.

It’s hard to shake the impression that what really bothered the court about Sicari’s night job was that it was too tacky a sideline for a jurist, even a lowly one.

Editorial, Pages 10 on 09/30/2013

Upcoming Events