Tensions mount at climate talks

Nearing end, negotiations stall over financing for poor nations

Residents affected by Tuesday’s storm walk back to their homes Thursday after receiving relief supplies in New Bataan township in the southern Philippines.
Residents affected by Tuesday’s storm walk back to their homes Thursday after receiving relief supplies in New Bataan township in the southern Philippines.

— DOHA, Qatar - U.N. climate talks are heading into the final stretch with a host of issues unresolved, including a standoff over how much money financially stressed rich countries can spare to help the developing world tackle global warming.

That issue has overshadowed the talks since they started last week in Qatar, the first Middle Eastern country to host the slow-moving annual negotiations aimed at crafting a global response to climate change.

Tensions grew Thursday - the penultimate day on the schedule - as the Philippines made an emotional call for action to keep global warming in check, citing the devastation caused by a powerful typhoon that killed about 420 people.

Meanwhile, Greenpeace and five other activist groups accused rich nations of pushing the talks to the “brink of disaster,” while a small group of warming skeptics appeared at a side event where they dismissed the entire process as a sham to transfer wealth to the poor world.

British climate-change skeptic Christopher Monckton even managed to slip into a conference hall where he addressed a plenary session, apparently mistaken for an official delegate.

A Tweet from the U.N. climate secretariat said he was “debadged and escorted out” of the venue “for impersonating a Party” and violating the conference’s code of conduct.

Rich nations pledged three years ago to deliver long-term financing to help poor nations switch to clean energy and adapt to rising sea levels and other impacts of global warming. They offered $10 billion a year in 2010-2012 in “fast-start” financing and said the amount would ramp up to $100 billion in 2020. But they didn’t say how.

Developing countries are demanding firm pledges before the Doha conference ends, such as a midterm target of $60 billion in the next three years, or written agreement that funds will be scaled up annually until 2020.But rich countries have been reluctant to make such commitments, citing the financial turmoil that is straining their budgets.

“We are not going to leave here with promises upon promises,” said Gambia delegate Pa Ousman Jarju, who represents a group of least developed countries. “The minimum that we can get out of here is a demonstration that there will be $60 billion on the table moving onward.”

Negotiators were working into the night trying to resolve that issue. They were also trying to finalize an agreement to formally extend the Kyoto Protocol, an emissions pact for rich countries that expires at the end of this year.

The U.S. never joined Kyoto while Japan, New Zealand, Canada and Russia don’t want to be part of the extension, meaning it would only cover about 15 percent of the world’s emissions of greenhouse gases.

Governments have set a deadline of 2015 to agree on a wider deal that would include both developed and developing countries, whichnow represent a majority of the world’s emissions.

Philippine envoy Naderev Sano said deadly storms such as Typhoon Bopha, which hit his country earlier this week, were nightmare scenarios the world may face more frequently if climate change is left unchecked.

“As we vacillate and procrastinate here, we are suffering,” he said. “Heartbreaking tragedies like this are not unique to the Philippines.”

Climate scientists say it’s difficult to link a single weather event to global warming. But some contend the damage caused by the recent Hurricane Sandy and other tropical storms was worse because of rising sea levels.

The goal of the U.N. talks is to keep temperatures from rising more than 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit, compared to preindustrial times. Temperatures have already risen about 1.4 degrees above that level, according to the latest report by the U.N.’s top climate body.

A recent projection by the World Bank showed temperatures are expected to increase by up to 7.2 degrees bythe year 2100.

“I’m getting concerned that ministers are not stepping up to the mark and providing solutions that we need at this stage of the game,” Gregory Barker, Britain’s minister of climate change, said.

“We need increased flexibility on all sides and a higher sense of urgency,” he said. “Developed countries also need to demonstrate a clear ambition across the board in terms of climate goals.”

Climate activists focused their criticism on developed nations. Kumi Naidoo of Greenpeace said the U.S., in particular, was a stumbling block to the negotiations.

The Obama administration has already taken some steps to rein in emissions, such as sharply increasing fuel efficiency standards for cars and trucks and investing in green energy. But a climate bill that would have capped U.S. emissions stalled in the Senate.

Information for this article was contributed by Bullit Marquez, Jim Gomez, Teresa Cerojano, Oliver Teves and Hrvoje Hranjski of The Associated Press.

Front Section, Pages 2 on 12/07/2012

Upcoming Events